Captain Nash's Bond elimination game...Best Bond Film

[Captain Nash]

Roll up ,roll up, roll up, boys and girls,ladies and gentleman, welcome to the Captian Nash Bond elimination game.
Simple to enter, fun to play, everyone can participate.
Simply copy and paste the last posters post, then add or ditract from the film you feel is better of worse.
One turn per day!
All films start with 5 points.
I've only included the EON films, as most people already know that CR'67 and NSNA are rubbish.

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (5)
Goldfinger (5)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (5)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (5)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (5)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (5)
Casino Royale (5)

Enjoy the game.

[stockslivevan]

Heh, CR is DEAD.


Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (6) +
Goldfinger (5)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (5)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (5)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (5)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (4) -
Casino Royale (5)

[Captain Nash]

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (6)
Goldfinger (5)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (5)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (5)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6) +1
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (3) -
Casino Royale (5)

[oscartheman]

What is this?
I have to take away form 1 to add to another?

[stockslivevan]

:?: What is this?
I have to take away form 1 to add to another?

Yes.

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (7) +
Goldfinger (5)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (5)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (5)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (2) -
Casino Royale (5)

[Kristatos]

:?: What is this?
I have to take away form 1 to add to another?

Yes.

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (7)
Goldfinger (6)+
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (5)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (4)-
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (2) -
Casino Royale (5)

[oscartheman]

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (7)
Goldfinger (6)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (6)+1
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (4)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (2)
Casino Royale (4)-1

[Harvey Wallbanger]

Gave 1 to dad -cr

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (7)
Goldfinger (6)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (6)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (4)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (3)
Casino Royale (3)

[stockslivevan]

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (8)+
Goldfinger (6)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (6)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (4)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (2)-
Casino Royale (3)

[Harvey Wallbanger]

Last vote stands -stockslivevan voted 2x in same day.

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (7)
Goldfinger (6)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (6)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (4)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (3)
Casino Royale (3)

[Kristatos]

Last vote stands -stockslivevan voted 2x in same day.

Christ, if you're gonna cheat, at least create multiple IDs so it won't look like you're cheating (should we close the game to newly registered forum members to prevent the pro-Craigers from doing just that?)

[Captain Nash]

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (7)
Goldfinger (6)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (6)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (4)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (2) -1
Casino Royale (4) +1


Play nice kids, I don't want to have to call uncle carl.
I think stocks had the right intention. If you look at the time he posted, they're different days. Yet not a complete 24 hours.

[Dr. No]

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (7)
Goldfinger (6)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (6)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (4)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (2) -1
Casino Royale (4) +1


Play nice kids, I don't want to have to call uncle carl.
I think stocks had the right intention. If you look at the time he posted, they're different days. Yet not a complete 24 hours.

I don't thnnk this will going to go anywhere unless there a elimiation rounds. It will be endless circle jerk of CR vs DAD.
I would suggest eliminating those two and see there the votes go.

If i gotta vote on it, Cr is not a Bond film IMHO, so I'll vote it down evey time and if Stocks has to vote on it Dad is his lest favorite. We'll be canceling eachother out eveyr day. Nobody will learn anything of interest and least not about eeach other that we don't already know.

we have a poll on best movies, 5 can be picked. viewtopic.php?f=5&t=635

[Captain Nash]

The game is fair, and will run its course.
Just because members do not agree on the films that are losing points, does not mean we have to change the format.
You can't really complain Doc, you've not voted yet.

[Dr. No]

The game is fair, and will run its course.
Just because members do not agree on the films that are losing points, does not mean we have to change the format.
You can't really complain Doc, you've not voted yet.

what is the course it has to run?
I think DAD and Cr are lighting rods distracting from the MR and YOLT in the group.

[Captain Nash]

Then vote for those films.

[Kristatos]

Play nice kids, I don't want to have to call uncle carl.
I think stocks had the right intention. If you look at the time he posted, they're different days. Yet not a complete 24 hours.

Oops, sorry, I thought it was one turn per week, not one per day.

[stockslivevan]

I'm not even gonna bother bumping CR so don't worry Dr. No. This is DCINB, it's dead, so there's no saving it, plus I don't think it's the best film on the list (hello FRWL). I'm still gonna downvote DAD for one simple reason: I think it's the worst Bond film. No complex strategy, just voting for whatever the best and worst is on the list. Since my last vote didn't count, I assume I get another chance today and then vote on the next day.

But there must be something clear. Is there a 24 hour limit or are we allowed to still vote within those hours? Say I vote at 11:59pm on one day then a minute later it's the next day and I get to vote again. Have I got that right? We should keep in mind that not everyone shares the same timezone.

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (8) +
Goldfinger (6)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (6)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (4)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (1) -1
Casino Royale (4)

I'll vote again on the 7th (in my timezone).

[Lady Elaine Fairchild]

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (8)
Goldfinger (6)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (7)+1
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (4)
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (1)
Casino Royale (3)-1

[carl stromberg]

Doctor No (5)
From Russia With Love (8)
Goldfinger (6)
Thunderball (5)
You Only Live Twice (5)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (7)
Diamonds Are Forever (5)
Live And Let Die (5)
The Man With The Golden Gun (5)
The Spy Who Loved Me (5)
Moonraker (5) + 1
For Your Eyes Only (5)
Octopussy (6)
A View To A Kill (5)
The Living Daylights (5)
Licence To Kill (5)
GoldenEye (5)
Tomorrow Never Dies (5)
The World Is Not Enough (5)
Die Another Day (1)
Casino Royale (2)-1

P.S: if Casino Royale (2006) is included - a rebooted departure from Cubby's Bond, then Never Say Never Again should be there too!