Captain Nash's Bond elimination game...Best Bond Film

[stockslivevan]

Doctor No (4)
From Russia With Love (25)+
Goldfinger (25)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (14) -1
The Living Daylights (13)

[Kristatos]

Doctor No (3) -1
From Russia With Love (25)
Goldfinger (25)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (14)
The Living Daylights (14) +1

[CaptainLewis]

Doctor No (2) -1
From Russia With Love (25)
Goldfinger (25)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (14) +1
The Living Daylights (14)

[Mazer Rackham]

Doctor No (3) +1
From Russia With Love (25)
Goldfinger (24)-1
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (14)
The Living Daylights (14)

[LilleOSC]

Doctor No (3)
From Russia With Love (24) -1
Goldfinger (25) +1
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (14)
The Living Daylights (14)

[Mazer Rackham]

Doctor No (4)+1
From Russia With Love (24)
Goldfinger (24) -1
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (14)
The Living Daylights (14)

[CaptainLewis]

Doctor No (3)-1
From Russia With Love (24)
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (15)+1
The Living Daylights (14)

[retrokitty]

Doctor No (4) +1
From Russia With Love (24)
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (14) -1
The Living Daylights (14)

I'm simply not willing to just let Dr. No go before Spy....

[Kristatos]

Doctor No (3) -1
From Russia With Love (24)
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (15) +1
The Living Daylights (14)

[stockslivevan]

Doctor No (3)
From Russia With Love (25)+
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (14) -
The Living Daylights (14)

[Capt. Sir Dominic Flandry]

Doctor No (2) -1
From Russia With Love (25)
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (15) + 1
The Living Daylights (14)

Sean has three left and is certain to win.

[Dr. No]

I'm sorry but Dr. No is simply the best of what is left and with out Dr No there'd be FRWL. Hell there'd be no series. I thought it get more respect than it has. A lowly 2!

Nothing against FRWL, it's my same old policy of take from the rich and give to Dr No

Doctor No (3) +1
From Russia With Love (24)1-
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (15)
The Living Daylights (14)

[carl stromberg]

Doctor No (3)
From Russia With Love (23) -1
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (16) + 1
The Living Daylights (14)

There are some corkers left Dr. ! I'll give From Russia With Love a minus just to annoy Stocksilvian when he next logs in.

[LilleOSC]

Doctor No (4) +1
From Russia With Love (22) -1
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (16) + 1
The Living Daylights (14)

[Kristatos]

Doctor No (3) -1
From Russia With Love (22)
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (17) + 1
The Living Daylights (14)

[CaptainLewis]

Doctor No (2) -1
From Russia With Love (22)
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (17)
The Spy Who Loved Me (18) + 1
The Living Daylights (14)

[retrokitty]

Doctor No (2)
From Russia With Love (22)
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (18) + 1
The Spy Who Loved Me (17) -1
The Living Daylights (14)

Shame Dr. No is so low... but I can see it's a lost cause. Maybe next time, Julius.

[stockslivevan]

You got it wrong Carl. It's not taking away points from FRWL, it's when it happens to DN.

Doctor No (2)
From Russia With Love (23)+
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (18)
The Spy Who Loved Me (16) -1
The Living Daylights (14)

Still, I honestly don't see how GF/TSWLM/TLD are any better than DN, IMO the quintessential Bond film. I can understand OHMSS, since I rate them very closely.

[Kristatos]

Still, I honestly don't see how GF/TSWLM/TLD are any better than DN, IMO the quintessential Bond film. I can understand OHMSS, since I rate them very closely.

I think DN's low-budget production values hamper it somewhat, along with the fact that everyone involved was still finding their feet and it didn't quite feel like a fully-formed Bond film, somehow. At least, those are my reasons for ranking it the least of the remaining Bond films (which are, admittedly, the cream of the crop). Like I keep saying, it's not a bad Bond film, by any means, it's just that the others are better.

[Capt. Sir Dominic Flandry]

Doctor No (1) -1
From Russia With Love (23)
Goldfinger (24)
On Her Majestys Secret Service (18)
The Spy Who Loved Me (17) +1
The Living Daylights (14)